Cigar It's a Knockout

[Shaun]

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 3
El Rey del Mundo - 10
H Upmann - 8
Juan Lopez - 11
Hoyo de Monterrey - 11
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
San Cristobal de Habana - 2
Trinidad - 12

[Rich B]

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 10
H Upmann - 8
Juan Lopez - 11
Hoyo de Monterrey - 11
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

Bye bye San Cristobal de Habana

[Budgie Smuggler]

+ JL
- Hoyo

[thedame007]

Admin

Bolivar - 12
Cohiba - 4
El Rey del Mundo - 10
H Upmann - 8
Juan Lopez - 12
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

[thedame007]

I agree the price point is high, which means it's a special occasion type smoke for me; how many have you smoked? I didn't think much of them at first, but after a few and after a couple with age I really started to appreciate how good they are

To be honest i have not had many - certainly less than a couple of handfuls, and not with any significant age on them. I just stopped searching them out after my general disappointment over price/quality, and decided to invest my money into more reliable and tasty sticks. However, i now may have to keep my mind and eyes more open to them again

[jerryr]

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 5
El Rey del Mundo - 10
H Upmann - 8
Juan Lopez - 12
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk

[anz3001]

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 10
H Upmann - 6
Juan Lopez - 12
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

[Simon Bolivar]

To be honest i have not had many - certainly less than a couple of handfuls, and not with any significant age on them. I just stopped searching them out after my general disappointment over price/quality, and decided to invest my money into more reliable and tasty sticks. However, i now may have to keep my mind and eyes more open to them again

Agree with Sheppsea, keep trying the occasional one - look for at least 5yrs age to judge them properly & I am sure they will grow on you. Never gonna be an every day smoke for us mere mortals & wouldn't want them to be but Birthdays & other red letter days, they take some beating.

[mcdee]

+Upmann -El Rey del Mundo

[thedame007]

ADMIN

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 6
El Rey del Mundo - 8
H Upmann - 7
Juan Lopez - 12
Hoyo de Monterrey - 9
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

[Horsebox]

I agree with [MENTION=13383428]sheppsea[/MENTION] and [MENTION=941]Simon Bolivar[/MENTION]

I've had a few young Siglo 1 which were ok and a Siglo 6 with but a year on it. It was a pleasant smoke but ultimately disappointing as I'd built it up in my mind. The Sig 3 and 4 I've had with 4/5 years on them were sublime in comparison. Well worth tracking down or stashing away for the future.

And with that:

Cohiba +

Juan Lopez -



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[gojira]

It' getting hard to choose which one to eliminate.

Hoyo +1 / ERdM -2

[thedame007]

ADMIN

Bolivar - 10
Cohiba - 7
El Rey del Mundo - 6
H Upmann - 7
Juan Lopez - 10
Hoyo de Monterrey - 10
Montecristo - 11
Partagas - 14
Por Larranaga - 12
Ramon Allones - 9
Trinidad - 12

[thedame007]

The Sig 3 and 4 I've had with 4/5 years on them were sublime in comparison. Well worth tracking down or stashing away for the future.

Thank you for the recommendations, i will try and source some of these

[handlebarpipe]

Cohiba + , PL -