If you could have only one of...

[Pilot]

... the cigars in the poll, which would you have? Please vote!

[satch]

Please God don't let this happen!

[Soulmanure]

That was easy. Why are there those other cigars alongside the 898? Confusing.

[Big J]

LOL!

[Big J]

That was easy. Why are there those other cigars alongside the 898? Confusing.

You're right, that was pretty easy.

[Corto Maltese]

I voted for the 898 too though I've never had one, nor any of the others either ( God I've gotta lot of catchin up to do !) but I thought that after all I've read about them that if was allowed to choose one cigar to get stuck on a desert island with then it would have to be something I'd love to try.
I hope my vote still counts !.

[Soulmanure]

I voted for the 898 too though I've never had one, nor any of the others either ( God I've gotta lot of catchin up to do !) but I thought that after all I've read about them that if was allowed to choose one cigar to get stuck on a desert island with then it would have to be something I'd love to try.
I hope my vote still counts !.

I'm always impressed with one who does his research--good call!

[bopmachine]

Another vote for Party D4. this simply is a great cigar that never fails to disapoint.

[daverave999]

Hmmm. Excellent question! Given the choice, I would go for the BBF as I just lurve Bolivars but it's not my fave of the brand.
Why these cigars in particular? Why just the one?

[Stevieboy]

JL1 for me and only because the JL2 is missing....

[tippexx]

Why these cigars in particular? Why just the one?

+1. And why the bias towards Partagas?


TriniRobboX for me.

[Soulmanure]

+1. And why the bias towards Partagas?

Because they're, oh, I don't know, better.

[tippexx]

Because they're, oh, I don't know, better.

Than Guantanamera maybe .... on a good day!

[Pilot]

Thank you all for sharing your preference!

Dave, tippexx, these cigars are in my list of cigars to sample. I compiled this list based on Internet reviews so it is incomplete and, in a way, arbitrary. I actually have the Bolivar Coronas Gigantes on the list, as well, but I had to restrict the number of choices to ten. My plan is to see which cigars top this poll and include them in a second poll with the rest in my list; although, I do suspect that satch will not be thrilled with that idea! .

For completeness , here is the whole list:

• Bolivar Belicosos Finos
• Bolivar Coronas Gigantes
• Diplomaticos No. 2
• H. Upmann MAGNUM 46
• H. Upmann Monarcas
• H. Upmann Sir Winston Cabinet
• H. Upmann Upmann No. 2
• Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure Especial
• Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 1
• Hoyo de Monterrey Epicure No. 2
• Hoyo de Monterrey Petit Robusto
• Juan Lopez Seleccion No. 1
• Montecristo A
• Montecristo Edmundo
• Montecristo Grand Edmundo Edicion Limitada 2010
• Montecristo No. 2
• Partagas 898
• Partagas Lusitanias
• Partagas Serie D Especial Edicion Limitada 2010
• Partagas Serie D No. 4
• Partagas Serie P No.2
• Partagas Shorts
• Punch Double Coronas
• Ramon Allones Specially Selected
• Romeo y Julieta Short Churchills
• Saint Luis Rey Double Coronas
• Saint Luis Rey Regios
• Saint Luis Rey Serie A
• San Cristobal de la Habana El Principe
• San Crist?bal de la Habana Muralla
• Trinidad Robusto Extra
• Vegas Robaina Clasicos
• Vegas Robaina Don Alejandro
• Vegas Robaina Famosos

[tippexx]

Thank you all for sharing your preference!

I do suspect that satch will not be thrilled with that idea!

I don't think Cohiba would be best pleased either Costas.