Desert island 🏝️ cigars

[NorthernPuro]

Choose any 8.

then of the 8 if you could only take one….

format….

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.

Then if I had to choose one

*

why:

[NorthernPuro]

1. Siglo VI
2. Fundadores
3. HU2
4. Cohiba Robusto
5. Lusi
6. HdM DC
7. Monte 2
8. Punch 898 Asia regional

Then if I had to choose one

Fundadores

why: most elegant in my opinion with great time enjoyment

[Simon Bolivar]

1/ Hoyo Epi No2
2/ ERDM DT
3/ RASCC
4/ R&J Panatela
5/ RAG
6/ Monte No1
7/ Cohiba CE
8/ Party 898

Only 1? ERDM DT with 10yrs+, coz their constistent, well constructed & great flav, that can be smoked at anytime.

[BullittBoy]

I still am quite early on in my cigar journey and have lots of sticks to try but for now my list is:

1. Monty 2
2. Monty Wide Edmundo
3. RYJ Wide Churchill
4. ERDM Choix Supreme
5. HDM Epi 2
6. Partagas D4
7. Monty Open Regata
8. Diplo No. 2

and for my only one pick would be.. the Monty 2 - consistently enjoyed them and each one feels like a special occasion!

[grumpybaldy]

1. ERDM DT
2. BBF
3. RASS
4. JL Selec 1
5. ERDM Choix du Roi
6. JL Chiado 1864
7. Bolivar Soberano
8. HdM Petit Robusto

My one to be saved from the waves: BBF - never fail

How about extending this (per DI Discs) to add a book, something for the beach that you'd recommend people to read if they haven't already? Mine would be 'Rogue Male' by Geoffrey Household.

A luxury? For a summer's day (ha ha!), a good Chablis to enjoy with my BBF...

[NorthernPuro]

Very good chaps! Yes book and luxury good additions

[smokey joe]

Party Short
Cohiba Siglo II
Boli Beli Finos
HdM DC
Punch Punch Punch
LGC Medaille D’Or #4
H.Upmann Mag 50
R&J Churchill (if just 1)

sunglasses
Precipice (Robert Harris)

[grumpybaldy]

Precipice (Robert Harris)

Hadn't heard of it; looks good. Hopefully has a proper ending - I've felt a few of his have buzzed along on an interesting historcal idea, but not had a conclusion to match.