Help me make my mind up!

[daverave999]

good quality, not too expensive and long lasting.

I don't think you'll go far wrong with the Hoyo then. I nearly get the same time as a full robusto out of mine, but then I smoke at quite a leisurely pace.

[monkey66]

For an alternate view I have had 2 boxes of Secretos and never got along with them.

[daverave999]

Have you tried any of these cigars before?

[jdawg]

good quality, not too expensive and long lasting.

The HR fit your criteria. As long as you don't smoke them like a cigarette, they will last you at least 45 min. - 1 hour.

If you wanted a more complex smoke, the Siglo II are good too.

[rollzst]

mmm i still cant decide on this, maybe i will have to buy all three haha.

i really like the secretos so the safe thing would be buy more of these, and the siglo 2 i think should also be a safe bet but i have been hearing great things about the PR's.

[jdawg]

I was going to suggest buying all three.

That would be your safe bet...

[peanutpete]

i vote for all three best bet safe option smoke them all fuck it its only money

[HabanoSy]

For me...

1. Hoyo Petit Robusto
2. Cohiba Secretos
3. Cohiba Siglo II

Hope this helps...

Cheers, HabanoSy

[mikes]

Not a big Cohiba fan so I would put the hoyos first....

[maltesefalcon]

Secretos

I would go for the Cohiba secretos too, packs so much flavour for such a small cigar. My fav cigar at the moment is Genios. Enjoy them what ever you decide.

[daverave999]

So what did you decide?

[rollzst]

So what did you decide?

I decided to go for a kind of spilt. 10 secretos, 10 siglo 2's and i got 5 epicure number 2 instead of the petit robustos.

[daverave999]

Nice.
FWIW, I find the Epi 2s quite different to the PRs.