Help me make my mind up!

[rollzst]

Ok so i am going to order a box of cigars. I am down to 3 suitable candidates. Which ones do you think would be the best to get:

1. Cohiba secretos
2. Hoyo petit robustos
3. cohiba siglo 2

[monkey66]

All good.
The PR's are the best value and smoke well young.
The Sig II's need a couple of years to start performing.

[Morris]

Hi rollzst, I've not tried any of these I'm afraid but in an effort to help you decide, have a look here:

http://www.cigars-review.org/

lots of botl submitted reviews.

I'm sure someone will be along in the meantime to help though.

I'll be in Manchester this weekend, are there any good Cigar shops?

Thanks.

[joebob96]

I just ordered a box

Just ordered a box about 5 min ago.

I went with cohiba siglo 2.

I wasn't exactly sure what I wanted so I picked up a siglo 4, a cohiba maduros, and a siglo 2. I ended up deciding on the siglo 2, for me it was the best all around cigar of the 3. Good size, ( the siglo 4 was too long ).

I recommend getting each one again just to jog your memory if it has been a while.

jb

[Lee Nub]

I have them all in the humi, all good but personally, and like was said value for money, go for the Hoyos. Those little buggers last for ages. Great flavours too.

Although the secretos do like a good while, im trying to age mine for a while before delving in the box again

[Lee Nub]

Hi rollzst, I've not tried any of these I'm afraid but in an effort to help you decide, have a look here:

http://www.cigars-review.org/

lots of botl submitted reviews.

I'm sure someone will be along in the meantime to help though.

I'll be in Manchester this weekend, are there any good Cigar shops?

Thanks.

Selfridges is meh, and get ready to bend over in there, ?33 for a padron 45th .

There is one , but for the life of me cant remember were it is lol

If you have the time, drive down to liverpool, shouldnt take more than 30 to 40 minutes, traffic depending lol, and visit

http://www.cgarsltd.co.uk/document.php?id=turmeaustobacconist.htm

I live smack bang in the middle of Manchester and Liverpool, yet havent ventured to any yet, still need to do something about that

[TJCoro]

What's the point of asking?

Just ordered a box about 5 min ago.

I went with cohiba siglo 2.

I wasn't exactly sure what I wanted so I picked up a siglo 4, a cohiba maduros, and a siglo 2. I ended up deciding on the siglo 2, for me it was the best all around cigar of the 3. Good size, ( the siglo 4 was too long ).

I recommend getting each one again just to jog your memory if it has been a while.
jb

Yo! Senor Joejob....you fucked up man ! The Secretos are far superior to the other two puros.


But what the Fuck do I know....after all, I'm just a plain ol' stupid lookin' dawg smiley standing guard in don TJ's stead !


Names Perro, El Perro, and the Cohiba Secretos are a Coro favorite. Why don't you make it yours


I'm too young to smoke, so I play with me balls, instead.

[rollzst]

Hi rollzst, I've not tried any of these I'm afraid but in an effort to help you decide, have a look here:

http://www.cigars-review.org/

lots of botl submitted reviews.

I'm sure someone will be along in the meantime to help though.

I'll be in Manchester this weekend, are there any good Cigar shops?

Thanks.

Yeah i have looked on there a few times thanks.

C.Aston cigar shop in the royal exchange arcade. The shop has a decent stock of good cigars but the prices are quite expensive. I only go in there for singles from time to time. The prices are much better than selfridges though.

By the way lee dub whats the cigar shop in bolton like?

[rollzst]

I have already got a box of secretos but i am tempted to get another box as they are so good but the other 2 i mentioned are tempting too!

[El Catador]

I am down to 3 suitable candidates. Which ones do you think would be the best to get

For what it's worth (0.02p, if that) I'd vote for the 'Secretos' as well.
Coffee and chocolate cream until the final third when the spice starts to appear.
Plus, they come in a lovely, sexy, black box (Now doesn't that thought sound good?).

[Lee Nub]

Never been to the one in Bolton either bud, i need to plan some time off lol

I agree with you Cat , the presentation of the Cohiba Maduro's is great, even my wife like mine lol

[daverave999]

Depends what your criteria are, but if it was me and I didn't have any of those already, I'd go for the Hoyo PR.

[rollzst]

Depends what your criteria are, but if it was me and I didn't have any of those already, I'd go for the Hoyo PR.

good quality, not too expensive and long lasting.

[satch]

Never had the secretos.
Of the other two I like the PR's.

[rollzst]

How long do the PR's generally last for?