Choose one cigar

[Simon G]

Size wise, Robusto for me

[tommy]

Choose one cigar

Pit bull muchacha not tried one but what a great name

A lovely NC. One of the best true NC's I've tried. By true NC, I mean not trying to emulate a Cuban.

[wolfie]

PSDN4 for me

[jim_twin]

Out of what Iv tried, it would be the Ramon Allones Specially Selected [emoji3]

[tommy]

Good choice, the RA Superiores are good too.

[mightyred]

This could help me as I've been mulling over what to purchase at dubai duty free


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Wigan]

HUHC

[Undercover]

Have to agree with Wolfie - would be the Party D4 for me too.

[mbro12]

Padron 64 Maduro Exclusivo

[TonyN]

Robusto size for me then either
D4S OR
BRC

[oskihen]

Robusto size for me then either
D4S OR
BRC

Which one only allowed one sir

[Makaron]

I would quit smoking. It would be the same if I had to choose one beer.

[oskihen]

I would quit smoking. It would be the same if I had to choose one beer.

Hypothetical question which one

[Undercover]

Pit bull muchacha not tried one but what a great name

I'm sure like a lot of people I skulked around the forum as a 'guest' for a few days before joining. I read Tommy's review of the Pit bull muchacha and it was a pivotal moment. It was like poetry - and I could almost taste and smell the cigar. So I thought 'let's do this' and joined! Still haven't tried one, but mainly because there are so many others to try. I'll get to it one day.

Focuses the mind a bit if you have to pick just one. I don't know if that gets ever more difficult the more you try or whether the more seasoned members of the forum actually find they've settled on their favourite(s) precisely because they've accumulated so much experience and knowledge?

[Simon-JG-hr]

Oooh! Such a tough decision!

I think I would narrow down the vitola to a belicos/pyramide of some description (but then I love Lonsdales too...). Beyond that it gets ridiculously tricky! If they were in good supply I'd ignore both of those vitolas and go with the Boli Coronas Extra. As they're discontinued, I'd probably be hard pushed to look beyond a BBF - but with lots of pressure from the PSPN2 and Party Short, not to mention something like a Vegas Robaina Famosos (as maybe I wouldn't want to only be tied down to things with more punchiness).

Yep... indecisiveness is an issue I suffer from occasionally...