Punch Medalla d'Oro

[Boozybillhiccup]

After a load of hype, is this the great cigar everyone expects Check out this video on YouTube:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX9tv8Nf8L8&feature=youtube_gdata_player

I won't be reviewing it three times....once was enough!! Rather spend my money on D'hOro nuts😜

[Manning]

Really enjoyed the review again, great intro!

Its a shame it didn't live up to your expectations, can't help wondering if they were focusing on the visual wow factor, rather than its smoking complexity. Hopefully it will improve with age.

Looking forward to your next review .

[Seriesteve]

Thanks for comments
Any others out there tried them and have an opinion on them
Ss
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1340444698.771218.jpg

[Jacobwaits]

Nice job guys...Have now smoked two and the first was very ordinary, not at all bad, but not great. However, I smoked a second one a few days later and it was so much tastier and the flavours more pronounced.
Really enjoyed it...Or it could just have been the scotch!

Keep up the good work.

Cheers.

[SteveGriff]

As usual Bill & Steve, great review.

I've only smoked one Punch M de Oro... and found it too one dimensional that made the large size of the Cigar a chore during the second half of the smoke... I have another one stocked away, will try again sometime next year and see how it goes.

Steve

[mb55317]

Haven't tried these yet and given the reviews on here I'm going to give them more time I think

[tippexx]

Haven't tried these yet and given the reviews on here I'm going to give them more time I think

I have a theory (I hope it's wrong). A rough 'edged' with a range of decent inherent flavours will mellow and improve with age, a well flavoured one dimensional cigar will simply mellow and cigars like the Cohiba 1966 or Upmann Half Corona which have pitifully poor flavours will not improve and will just become a weakened version of the rubbish they already are.

[Boozybillhiccup]

Thank you all for your comments... keep em coming :-)/

[Seriesteve]

I have a theory (I hope it's wrong). A rough 'edged' with a range of decent inherent flavours will mellow and improve with age, a well flavoured one dimensional cigar will simply mellow and cigars like the Cohiba 1966 or Upmann Half Corona which have pitifully poor flavours will not improve and will just become a weakened version of the rubbish they already are.

You tried em yet ?
Ss

[Bad-Yeti]

Great review, many thanks.

Shame, I was really hoping for great things from these