MOST DISAPPONTING CIGAR 2010

[peanutpete]

Following on from Nics thread about the best cigar and best new cigar 2110
what has been your most disapponting cigar of the year, not your worst cigar (some one else can do that one) but the the one you thought would be much better than it was, i'll go first and i have only had one but for me itwas the R&J wide churchill was very under filled and did not do much for me

[Watkins]

I'll let you know in a hundred years.


My first year smoking, but a cohiba robusto, put me off the brand for being over priced really.

[monkey66]

R and J wide Churchill as per Pete

Punch Serie D'oro No 1 UK regional, just did nothing for me end to end

[Drewmidorn]

Smoking a really disappointing Edmundo right now...

[monkey66]

Smoking a really disappointing Edmundo right now...

All Edmundos are disappointing IMHO, however the Petit Edmundo's are great.

[Habana-Habanos]

All Edmundos are disappointing IMHO, however the Petit Edmundo's are great.

+1

[SteveGriff]

+1

+2 here.

The Petit Edmundo's are the bomb. The Edmundo's are the ....

[Drewmidorn]

All Edmundos are disappointing IMHO, however the Petit Edmundo's are great.

really funny you should say that. I bought 3 petit edmundo tubes on the way out to Doha to keep in my pocket and they were great so i thought I'd give the edmundo another go... not even close.

D

[Smallclub]

+2 here.

The Petit Edmundo's are the bomb. The Edmundo's are the ....

+3 here!

As for the most disappointing cigar in 2010 it's the Monte Sublimes EL.

[Big_T_UK]

After all the hype, price and BS posted about them I would put the Behike range as the biggest let down. Not a bad cigar, just weird.

[Robusto]

+4 re the Petit Edmundo.

[Kdot]

After all the hype, price and BS posted about them I would put the Behike range as the biggest let down. Not a bad cigar, just weird.

+1

After all thr hype I expected something Earth Shattering...What I got was a decent smoke, good but far from great.

[cohibaIV]

R and J short Churchill as per Pete

Punch Serie D'oro No 1 UK regional, just did nothing for me end to end

He said 'WIDE'....'Edit'....

[cohibaIV]

+1

After all the hype I expected something Earth Shattering...What I got was a decent smoke, good but far from great.

After smoking a 52...Loverly cigar but the Hype just did not meet the smoke...

Reminds me of the Opus X Hype about a cigar....Great marketing but the end product did not send me to cloud nine..

[monkey66]

He said 'WIDE'....'Edit'....

He sure did and so did I (I just wrote 'short' cos I am stupid )