Interesting Cohiba Review

[Soulmanure]

I have yet to have a Cohiba--it's next on the list of must-try cigars. However, I keep hearing quite a bit of back-and-forth on this brand and just read this less than salutary review in the following:

http://www.cigarinspector.com/cohiba/overpriced-brand-name-cigar-thou-name-is-cohiba

I'm still probably going to try some Siglo IV's sooner than later, but I hear a lot of people throw the terms "overpriced" and "overrated" at these sticks, and then there are those who've got nothin' but love. Is this just a matter of preference?

[satch]

I've only had the Siglo 2. Very nice, but IMO there are just as good smokes for a bit less moolah.

[Simon-JG-hr]

I'd argue vehemently against over-rated. I've had quite a few Cohibas, and all have been exceptional - for me it's the consistency which makes them so good.

Over-priced, on the other hand, is possibly a fairer accusation. Then again, they are very good (in my opinion) and you pays your money you takes your choice... That said, a couple of quid of the price would be greatly appreciated from my viewpoint...

We had a similar debate about the whole over-priced/over-rated thing at JJF during the SLR evening a few weeks ago. General consensus seemed to be that they have an excellent reputation for a reason, but the crowd was split on the price issue...

[Daize]

The Cohiba Robusto is a very good cigar. A bit over-priced ? Maybe, but to be honest I think it is fair value. It is a very complex and interesting cigar, either the guys palate ain't up to it, he was unlucky, or they were just really young though, I find a young Cohiba Robusto to be just fine.

[michael69]

one opinion based on one cigar........

I love them (and many other Cohibas)

[bigbarneyhotdog]

Cohiba, mmm coffee beans

[68TriShield]

I don't have sensitive enough taste buds to justify the extra money for Cohiba cigars.
With that said,the ones I've smoked have been excellent.

[Soulmanure]

I don't have sensitive enough taste buds to justify the extra money for Cohiba cigars.
With that said,the ones I've smoked have been excellent.

I probably don't either, but I do want to experience some just to see.

It sounds like the general view is that they are consistent, excellent cigars that could do well with a price adjustment.

[Gryph]

After trying many brands (in Cuba no less), Cohiba was the favourite by far. For me, the somewhat unique 'cohiba' flavour was what did it, both on the draw, smoke and aftertaste. Of course, these things are very personal - each to their own.

Favourite is the Robusto by miles, with the Siglo VI a close second. The V and IV I tried were also very good. Esplendido ... wasn't that fussed, but I think it was too long for me

If you were to try any, I can back the robusto (as do a cab in my humidor) as a great example.

Of course, this is from someone who found a Oliva V too 'sweet' and R&J too 'perfumy, nasty aftertaste'. H-Upmann Junior Tubo on one night just didn't work, but the other night (non tubo) it did!

But after trying everything, the Cohiba Robusto works every time for me.

EDIT: to add ... after reading that review - everything is subjective. I tried an Edmundo before the Cohiba Robusto. Edmundo, very good, smooth, but to be honest lacked that 'something', and certainly lacked the 'smell'. That said, it may have been a badly stored one! I've got 25 robusto laid down, 25 siglo VI, and to be honest, adding 25 Edmundo would be nice.

[Gryph]

I probably don't either, but I do want to experience some just to see.

It sounds like the general view is that they are consistent, excellent cigars that could do well with a price adjustment.

For 1 stick.. try it. Same you'd (I'd?!) spend on a decent bottle of vino... what's the worst that can happen?

[Soulmanure]

For 1 stick.. try it. Same you'd (I'd?!) spend on a decent bottle of vino... what's the worst that can happen?

No doubt. Indeed, I don't mind trying a three- or five-pack out, but if I'm going to invest in a box, and I can get 50 kick ass cigars for the price of 25 of these, I hesitate, particularly given that I like to be able to sit down to a relatively regular smoke and not freak out about my credit card statement.

On the other hand, I have dreams of buying four boxes of everything, storing it all in a gigantic walk-in humidor, and exhaling in total satisfaction as my wife brings me a bourbon.

[bigbarneyhotdog]

Lanceros are the danglies! Older the better.

[TJCoro]

I second that review.

I have yet to have a Cohiba--it's next on the list of must-try cigars. However, I keep hearing quite a bit of back-and-forth on this brand and just read this less than salutary review in the following:

http://www.cigarinspector.com/cohiba/overpriced-brand-name-cigar-thou-name-is-cohiba

I'm still probably going to try some Siglo IV's sooner than later, but I hear a lot of people throw the terms "overpriced" and "overrated" at these sticks, and then there are those who've got nothin' but love. Is this just a matter of preference?

I read that review the other day senor soulman, and somewhat agree.

I have been a big fan of the Cohiba line for many years, especially the VI and secretos. But lately, the robustos have been leaving me wanting.

I thought it was me, but after reading the review, maybe not.

I'm still big fan and hoping a few years in the humidor will correct the deficiencies I've noticed in recent productions.

Well, (hic) that's what I think, anyway (hic).






Hey El Perro. If you don't want 'em, I have a box you can put them in.

[nicwing]

An almost sensible post from TJ, well that's a first.

I am like many here on this thread in that I find the Cohiba hype and to a greater extent the price has put me off. I look at them a bit like Crystal Champagne and Hip Hopists in that they almost appear a badge of honour or prestige.

But price and bling aside, I have to say that I have smoked very few and am not really qualified to judge but the Siglo IV tubo I smoked sitting outside Franco's in Jermyn street last summer with three very good friends is without doubt the very best cigar I have ever smoked (and it was a gift so I don't have that light walleted after taste either!)

If this thread does one thing it's to make me want to try some more and try to keep an open mind.

[moidoid]

I have a box of Cohiba Robustos gently doing their thing since 2006. Perhaps I should crack them open this summer and report back. I have a few Cohiba lying around - a Siglos VI, and Esplendido & a LE Piramide but I don't think I've ever tried one! I think that they just feel too expensive to smoke...