Cigar of The Year

[cohibaIV]

Duke....

[ChrisMClark]

I'm voting for the Guantanamera Cristale as my number one


*runs for cover*

Joking

[MaledettoToscano]

I'm voting for the Guantanamera Cristale as my number one

Whatever rocks your boat

[kingcohiba]

wow this is a tough one! i can tell you my top 4 and pick which one you like.

arturo fuente anejo 77 shark-friday night, the best one i have ever had!

montecristo sublime-halloween night

padron family reserve 45th anniversary- hallooween afternoon

bolivar gold medal-Thanksgiving night

had the duke as well and it was pretty dang good. up there for sure, but not one of the best all year.

[ChrisMClark]

Whatever rocks your boat

Much more civil response than I was expecting having said the 'G' word lol, I thought I'd have to run like fuck for a minute!

[Stevieboy]

JL #2 for me...I only discovered it early this year and I'm blown away...bliss every time...

[Robusto]

Much more civil response than I was expecting having said the 'G' word lol, I thought I'd have to run like fuck for a minute!

It's a must-have lol.

[Robusto]

JL #2 for me...I only discovered it early this year and I'm blown away...bliss every time...

You've corrupted many!
Well done, SBoy.

I brought a box back from Havana - from the Partagas factory - and they are a totally different colour to a box I bought online. It's remarkable. Like black vs white.

Actually the ones from Havana look like they are getting over scabies. Really wart-y and veined compared to the smooth biatches I already had.

Both cigar batches taste wonderful so I'm not worried in the slightest about possibly having been fake-shafted.

[MaledettoToscano]

Much more civil response than I was expecting having said the 'G' word lol, I thought I'd have to run like fuck for a minute!

Nah.. . I'd never start a flame because of someone elses taste, though I couldn't really belive you

[Stevieboy]

Oh no....he's off again

The P1 was just a sexual experience and in a league of its own.

[Deano]

As TJ's not around; don't care much for the JL2. I know I'm probably the first on the forum to say it, but it just doesn't do it for me.

[cohibaIV]

As TJ's not around; don't care much for the JL2. I know I'm probably the first on the forum to say it, but it just doesn't do it for me.

Love em, and the JL#1

[Kdot]

As TJ's not around; don't care much for the JL2. I know I'm probably the first on the forum to say it, but it just doesn't do it for me.

Boy are you insane? or just looking for a fight? I discovered these a few months a go and its now my regular cigar. I've never came across a TRUE BOTL who didn't like em. Each to their own I guess but i'm starting a campaign to get your afficionado pass revoked by contacting the owner of this forum...

F**K it im gonna add some more controversy, I think the JL2 is better than the Duke. IMO the Duke is over rated and should not be smoked right away The RyJ Churchill is a better smoke. The Duke could do with a year on it before being considered great.

I really only wanted 1 nomination each but since we're all listing the contents of our humidor here's my top 3 in order.

1. Padilla 1948 Robusto - best cigar I've had this year hands down.
2. Partagas P2
3. Montecristo Sublime

[Robusto]

Oh no....he's off again

It's true tho, SBoy.
It was like an eruption in a Teddington basement.
Taste This.

[kingcohiba]

Boy are you insane? or just looking for a fight? I discovered these a few months a go and its now my regular cigar. I've never came across a TRUE BOTL who didn't like em. Each to their own I guess but i'm starting a campaign to get your afficionado pass revoked by contacting the owner of this forum...

F**K it im gonna add some more controversy, I think the JL2 is better than the Duke. IMO the Duke is over rated and should not be smoked right away The RyJ Churchill is a better smoke. The Duke could do with a year on it before being considered great.

I really only wanted 1 nomination each but since we're all listing the contents of our humidor here's my top 3 in order.

1. Padilla 1948 Robusto - best cigar I've had this year hands down.
2. Partagas P2
3. Montecristo Sublime

unfortunately, i have to agree with this maniac.....i too think the jl2 is better than the duke. although the duke i think is a very good cigar. i also have to agree on the padillas! although i have not had the 1948, ive has several others that have been simply amazing.