Cigar of The Year

[Kdot]

Shit-stirrer

im known to walk around with a big wooden spoon

[Kdot]

anymore nominations before I get a poll going?

[cj121]

In terms of what I've had the most, I'm going to plump for the JL2, despite a few inconsistencies.

[Stevieboy]

I think the JL2 is better than the Duke. IMO the Duke is over rated and should not be smoked right away The RyJ Churchill is a better smoke. The Duke could do with a year on it before being considered great.

Agree completely K-man...I've loved the couple of Dukes I've tried so far but I reckon in a year or so they'll mebbe be fit to take on the mighty JL#2....who will win? Only one to find out.....FIGHT!

[Stevieboy]

As TJ's not around; don't care much for the JL2. I know I'm probably the first on the forum to say it, but it just doesn't do it for me.

Jeez Deano...did you try one from a bad box maybe?
Give them another try from another box....#

BTW..if you've any you want to off-load or swap...PM me

[jdawg]

This is tough one!

If I go by what I smoked most of this year, it would be the Partagas Shorts. I can't get enough of them. They are flavorful and consistent.

My top list would be:

1) Partagas Shorts
2) H. Upmann Mag 48 LE
3) A. Fuente Anejo Shark
4) Alec Bradley Tempus

Have not tried the Duke yet, so can't comment on that one.

[Boss Hog]

Interesting that there have not been many nominations for NC's

1. Partagas SP2 - Never lets me down.
2. Rocky Patel Decade
3. Hoyo Regalos LE 2007