The polls are in

[G-man]

Whats not to like

Probably because We smoke more cigars. And their are more cigar smokers in the U S
But The Pie is way to the NC side for only a 10% differance! IMHO

Do you think I should do another one with the same question but regarding the taste?
That would be great,as we don't want this to look 1 sided .

LMAO ROTF
I could care less which is better constructed!
Everydays differant
I smoke what I like
And I like what I smoke
Could be CC
Could be NC
Does it really matter ?
Its all a matter of TASTE
and being a BOTL here
That really matter

TO ME ANYWAY
THANKS

__________________
Cigar Reviews & News at CigarInspector.com

[daverave999]

Yeah fair point gss, was just thinking that those in the US probably smoke a proportionately larger number of NCs so might have different views to those who smoke mostly Cubans.

[ACMCC]

Fair point Dave, I think the poll is about right, but there are a fair amount of NC's I've tried that the draw is maybe a little too free, a little resistance is preferable IMHO, on the other hand CC have a wider variance, NC's are more consistent, Looks don't really mean a lot, most are just different shade's! so internal construction (draw) is the main concern.
Taste wise CC would probably just edge it, if you take the top 20 brands of each and compare, again it depends on personal preference. if you have a large collection - then CC's win hands down, as you would have stock going back many years and aged Cubans are generally better tasting, this would hold true if you took a sample of score's from the aged reviews of CA etc.

The problem I find is that generally with CC's the more you pay the better the cigar, but with NC's this is not true as a pricey NC may have a cracking marketing campaign but taste poor! I think NC's may have a few bargains, I had a good one the other night, but can't remember what it was or know how much it cost! was not expecting much as it did not have a very fancy band etc.....

[CigarInspector]

The new poll is there!

http://www.cigarinspector.com/other/poll-discussion-cigars-taste

[CigarInspector]

And here are the results of both polls:

[monkey66]

Quite strong numbers on the taste test.