San Cristobal La Punta or El Morro?

[tommy]

So I'm looking at these San cristobal cigars for a box buy with an older box code. The other box I'm interested in is the RyJ exhibition no4 also with over 10 years on them. I found John's review of the La Punta with a recommendation for the El Morrow so I'm thinking if the two the EM may be the choice smoke but what do you guys think and what about the RyJ?
So come on chaps, who likes what? Vote below.

[tommy]

SC LP


SC EM


RyJ E no4

[JoeyGunz]

I know where you're looking and your best bet is to post the factory codes and dates here and see if anybody has experience with them

[PeeJay]

The way you're hoovering up stock we'd better be seeing some stash photos soon Tommy

[tommy]

The way you're hoovering up stock we'd better be seeing some stash photos soon Tommy

Urm... Er... I um.... Smoked them all [emoji16]
When my first scuba is full I'll lay it out for a snap.

[tommy]

Ok I've edited all the identifying info out. No doubt everyone knows but I feel I've done due diligence. Here are the SC choices:
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1404461307.281475.jpg
And the RyJ:
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1404461391.475272.jpg
Advice please. I may just buy nothing too of course, I have boxed on the way already so prob shouldn't but I don't have much with age.

[Stevieboy]

I always think there's a reason that there's aged stock from certain years still kicking around. This vendor ( who I buy from a lot - great service, super reliable) has had this stock for ages now....I'd be a bit wary of quality Tommy....

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

[PeeJay]

Good advice Stevieboy

[tommy]

I always think there's a reason that there's aged stock from certain years still kicking around. This vendor ( who I buy from a lot - great service, super reliable) has had this stock for ages now....I'd be a bit wary of quality Tommy....

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

That's the reason for this thread, I find it odd too. I want it to be good hence the request for feedback but I feared there must be a reason. Some if it is cheaper than the new stock!

[ValeTudoGuy]

It's going to come down to wether its worth the punt for you?

[tommy]

In the end I decided that the answer was no. I am keen in getting some old stock but for now I can bide my time.

[ValeTudoGuy]

Fair do's, good things come to those who wait.

[Sligub]

Tommy if it helps I've bought a couple of boxes of the mag46 from him to split and they've always been good

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

[tommy]

That is good to know thanks, how are the mag46? Fancy a trade?

[tommy]

Did someone send me one of these?