Ageing of Tubed Cigars

[butternutsquashpie]

No, he was most likely salving the blokes price preconceptions and took an easy way out because he couldn't be bothered explaining the reasoning and decision to tube some vitola or explain why the price difference .... or he just wanted to get to the cantina and his works Culabras.

All food for thought. But why lie about a product that would make less money? methinks he would hype up the tubes if that were the case!

But all in all, amazing discussion here! I love how 3 tubes threads popped up in the span of 3 months or so and each yielded a new field of discourse

Sent from my BlackBerry 9100 using Tapatalk

[Stevieboy]

All food for thought. But why lie about a product that would make less money? methinks he would hype up the tubes if that were the case!

But all in all, amazing discussion here! I love how 3 tubes threads popped up in the span of 3 months or so and each yielded a new field of discourse

Sent from my BlackBerry 9100 using Tapatalk

Well, I believe you mate

Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk

[butternutsquashpie]

Insanity is best shared.

But then again, we're the majority, eh Stevie

Sent from my BlackBerry 9100 using Tapatalk

[TJCoro]

Down with Tubos!

I don't mind the Boli RC and it is a good example, even when young, of where a tube version IS MHO far superior.

( Psst! Pipe down mi amigo, senor tripleXXX. You"ll create a run on RC tubos!)

Ahem! Right then....the official Coro position is "why pay more for a tube when you can get the same puro for less without the tube."

HEY! LOOK OVER THERE!
I think I saw someone on this fine forum offering the latest Cohiba Limited Edition! Let's all go look at that!



Perro, el Perro


HaHa! Your are incredulous, el P!


(Hurumph!) Indeed! And you are still A BOOB!


He Ray Jay...were the HELL are we?

[butternutsquashpie]

Psst! Pipe down mi amigo, senortripleXXX. You"ll create a run on RC tubos!
Ahem! Right then....the official Coro position is "why pay more for a tube when you can get the same puro for less without the tube."

Perro, el Perro

HaHa! Your are incredulous, el P!
(Hurumph!) Indeed! And you are still A BOOB!

Because they taste a tad better? To some. I mean c'mon. Not a single Coro thought soo?

Sent from my BlackBerry 9100 using Tapatalk

[tippexx]

...and furthermore chico Cube, according to some, tubed puros age better, but slower.

From my limited experience with tubed sticks, I find well-aged and cared for tubed puros superior to non-tubed puros.

But that's just me.

Me too. The tubes slow down the aging process, allowing ammonia and nicotines to dissipate allowing full scope to the flavours and retaining the depth of flavour.

Min Ron Nee advocates much the same for un-tubed sticks, in that the aging processed can be controlled and slowed by plastic/shrink wrapping boxes and maintaining them at a lower than usual temperature. There are also BOTL who believe that aging can be accelerated by storing boxes at a higher than usual temperature in foil wrap. (The boxes are put through a freezing treatment first before attempting either).

The cigar factories have been putting smokes in tubes for a long time, OK the tubes do make useful transporters, but if as some would have us believe tubes are just a marketing gimmick or some sort of metalic camouflage for poorer sticks then why aren't more vitola tubed? Are the blends for the Boli Tubos No 2 and Petit Coronas the same? To be honest I don't know, but smoke them and you'll notice the Tubos is more intense in flavour and power.

Now, a nice thing about tubos is they have a common factor, and it doesn't matter if they're MAR 13 Upmann Coronas Junior or pre-Embargo Bolivar Churchills, when you buy them you buy them caps ON. If H&F or any of our vendors thought that tubos should be stored with their caps OFF they would either do it or advocate it .... they don't .... and given that some of them have a hundred or so years of experience in storing cigars I think they know what they're doing.

Someone posted earlier that posted that they removed their cigars from tubes because the tubes spoiled the aesthetics of their humidor .... which, if that is the criteria kinda beggars the question why buy a tubed cigar in the first place if you can get an untubed version? If it's just for transportation then that base is covered, Mitch can sell you an inexpensive flexible tube that will carry Demi Tasse or Churchills.

Not often TJ and I agree .... but I'm with the Coro's on this .... keep the caps ON.

[Simon Bolivar]

+1 Agree with Arf & CJ, what ever next!

[Tomothebuilder]

I had an issue with white mold on a box of tubed R&J Churchills, I've heard that this is more common with tubed cigars than untuned to I took them all out of the tubes, brushed the white mold off and put them in the humidor "untubed" and not had a propel since. Anyone else experienced this with tubes?

[rascal]

I had an issue with white mold on a box of tubed R&J Churchills, I've heard that this is more common with tubed cigars than untuned to I took them all out of the tubes, brushed the white mold off and put them in the humidor "untubed" and not had a propel since. Anyone else experienced this with tubes?

Yip I have bought tubes with mold on them but I have also had boxes delivered with mold on them, so dont know if the mold is caused the same way on both but retailers dont check tubes like they do boxes so goes unnoticed a lot more. So more end customers are the ones dealing with cleaning it off.

[Cubist]

Well it appears that the tubed cigars tend to age slower and have better flavour. I imagine the restricted oxygen may slow aging, and the fact they are sealed may also reduce the amount of essential oils lost to the atmosphere, so helping to maintain good flavour.

So I suppose I should stop decanting them, and start placing the sealed tubes directly into the humi. Well I didn't think i would be saying that when I started this thread. Doh!

[Tomothebuilder]

Hmm so it would seem. The problem is I threw away the tubes for my Churchills when I moved house!

[Cubist]

Hmm so it would seem. The problem is I threw away the tubes for my Churchills when I moved house!

Same here. Slung the tubes for my Romeo Churchills once I'd put them in the humi.

[SHAMZ84]

Quite interesting post. Just read through it...so many different theory's.

I've recently just bought a few metal and glass tubos,
I just ended up uncapping them and placing them in the humi....

The glass one looked air tight and had a dampened small sponge..however this was a NC though.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[PeeJay]

As this post seems to have been reanimated images.jpeghere's another thought. Cigar manufacturers seems to be moving towards the tubes that are split halfway rather than having a screw cap. Is this just a design affectation and is the seal as good as a screw thread?

images-2.jpeg

[SHAMZ84]

sorry didn't want to created another thread...Looking at some site, they were saying this is the new premium type of tube.